Includes both current and previous cast.
| Name | First Appearance | Last Appearance | Previous Appearances |
| ---------------------------- | ---------------- | --------------- | -------------------- |
| [[Aaron Dalla Villa]] | | | |
| [[Alonso Guzman]] | | Jan 2025 | |
| [[Andrea Farley Shimota]] | Feb 2025 | | |
| [[Andrea Murillo]] | Feb 2025 | | |
| [[Annie Grove]] | | | |
| [[Babou Sanneh]] | Mar 2025 | | |
| [[Brandin Steffensen]] | | | Start-Sep 2024 |
| [[Brendan Duggan]] | | | |
| [[Bria Bacon]] | | Jul 2024 | |
| [[Cara Diaz]] | Aug 2024 | Jan 2025 | |
| [[Casey Bronwyn Howes]] | | | |
| [[Catheryn Clifford]] | Nov 2024 | | |
| [[Charles-Alexis Desgagnés]] | | Jan 2025 | |
| [[Christoper Ralph]] | Jan 2025 | | |
| [[Collin Baja]] | Sep 2024 | | |
| [[Derek Tabada]] | | | |
| [[Dorchel Haqq]] | | Jan 2025 | |
| [[Douglas Burkhadt]] | Nov 2024 | | |
| [[Douglas J Gillespie]] | | Jan 2025 | |
| [[Erik Debono]] | Nov 2024 | | |
| [[Eriko Jimbo]] | Sep 2024 | | |
| [[Evelyn Chen]] | Jul 2024 | | |
| [[Gabriella Sibeko]] | | | |
| [[Hannah Straney]] | Jan 2025 | | |
| [[Heather Lang]] | | | Start-Aug 2024 |
| [[Ian Bedford]] | Sep 2024 | Jan 2025 | |
| [[Jacob Michael Warren]] | | | |
| [[Jacob Nahor]] | Jan 2025 | | |
| [[Jennifer Florentino]] | | | |
| [[Jesse Kovarsky]] | Aug 2024 | | |
| [[Jodi McFadden]] | | | |
| [[Jonathan Colafrancesco]] | Dec 2024 | | |
| [[Karl Kenzler]] | | Jan 2025 | |
| [[Kevin M Pajarillaga]] | | | |
| [[Kim Fischer]] | | | |
| [[Leigh-Ann Esty]] | Jan 2025 | | |
| [[Luca Renzi]] | | Jan 2025 | |
| [[Madeline Wright]] | | | |
| [[Madison Olandt]] | Jan 2025 | | |
| [[Majella Bess Loughran]] | | | |
| [[Maleek M Washington]] | | Jan 2025 | |
| [[Marc J Cardarelli]] | | | |
| [[Marla Phelan]] | | | |
| [[Mia DiLena]] | | | |
| [[Mio Ishikawa]] | Mar 2025 | | |
| [[Miguel Miranda]] | Mar 2025 | | |
| [[Mikaela Sinclair Brandon]] | Jan 2025 | | |
| [[Mike Tyus]] | | Dec 2024 | |
| [[Nando Morland]] | | Jan 2025 | |
| [[Nathaniel Buchsbaum]] | | | |
| [[Ny Opong]] | Dec 2024 | | |
| [[Parker Murphy]] | | | |
| [[Patrick Ferreri]] | Sep 2024 | | |
| [[Rachel Harris]] | Nov 2024 | | |
| [[Randolph Curtis Rand]] | | Jan 2025 | |
| [[Raymond Ejiofor]] | | | |
| [[Reshma Gajjar]] | | Jan 2025 | |
| [[Robert Vail]] | | Oct 2024 | |
| [[Ryan VanCompernolle]] | | | |
| [[Sophie Bortolussi]] | | Jan 2025 | |
| [[Spencer William Grossman]] | Feb 2025 | | |
| [[Steve Bangerter]] | Apr 2025 | | |
| [[Steven James Apicello]] | | | |
| [[Tiffany Violet De Alba]] | | | |
| [[Tony Bordonaro]] | | Jan 2025 | |
| [[Tony Torn]] | | Jan 2025 | |
| [[Tori Sparks]] | | | |
| [[Victoria DeRenzo]] | Aug 2024 | | |
| [[Zach Martens]] | Jan 2025 | | |
| [[Zach McNally]] | Feb 2025 | | |
| [[Zachary Eisenstat]] | Feb 2025 | | Start-Jan 2025 |
*In case a performer appears in a performance after their "Last Appearance", the original appearance dates will be moved to "Previous Appearances".